Why Your Website Is Losing Customers Due to SSL Issues

January 5, 2026

Imagine this situation: a potential customer searches for your services on Google, clicks the link to your website, and instead of seeing your offer, they see a red warning: “Your connection is not private.” What do they do? In 84% of cases, they simply close the tab and go to your competitor.

This isn’t a hypothetical scenario. It’s the everyday reality of thousands of Polish small businesses that have an SSL certificate installed—but configured incorrectly. And they lose real money because of it every single day.

Why SSL Is Not “Just a Technical Thing”

Most business owners think of SSL as a technical requirement—something you “need to have,” but not necessarily understand. The problem is that a misconfigured SSL has a direct, measurable impact on your revenue.

Hard Data: How Much You Lose Because of SSL Issues

Studies show that:

  • 84% of users leave a website immediately after seeing a warning about an unsecured connection
  • 95% of people won’t come back to a site that showed them a security warning
  • Sites with properly configured SSL rank higher in Google (it’s been an official ranking factor since 2014)
  • No SSL or incorrect configuration can reduce conversions by up to 80%

If your website generates 1,000 visits per month and, in theory, 5% could turn into customers (50 leads), then with SSL problems you may be losing up to 40 of those leads. If your average transaction value is 2,000 PLN, you’re losing 80,000 PLN per month. Per year? Nearly a million PLN.

And all of that because of something that can be fixed in 2 hours.

The Most Common SSL Mistakes in Polish Businesses

In Poland the situation is especially problematic. Many small businesses have an SSL certificate installed (often automatically by hosting), but nobody has ever checked whether it actually works correctly. Here are the most common issues I see:

1. Mixed Content

This is the most common problem. Your site runs on HTTPS, but some elements—images, JavaScript scripts, fonts—are still loaded over HTTP. The browser detects this and either shows a warning or blocks those elements entirely.

Typical symptoms:

  • The logo doesn’t display correctly
  • Some product photos are missing
  • The contact form doesn’t work
  • An exclamation mark appears in the address bar instead of a padlock

2. Expired Certificate

Free Let’s Encrypt certificates (used by most Polish small businesses) are only valid for 90 days and must be renewed automatically. If auto-renewal fails, the certificate expires and every visitor gets a scary red warning.

3. No Redirect from HTTP to HTTPS

Some businesses have SSL installed but didn’t configure redirects. That means the website works both at http://yourdomain.com and https://yourdomain.com. The problem? Google sees this as duplicate content (SEO penalty), and some users still land on the unsecured HTTP version.

4. Incorrect Certificate Chain

Sometimes the certificate is installed but intermediate certificates are missing. Modern browsers can handle this, but older versions (especially on Android) will show a warning.

5. Incompatible Protocols and Ciphers

The server may be using outdated SSL/TLS protocols or weak ciphers that modern browsers consider unsafe.

How to Check Your Website’s SSL Status (2 Minutes)

You don’t have to be a developer to check whether your SSL works correctly. There’s a free tool that will do it for you in 2 minutes.

Step 1: SSL Labs Test

  1. Go to ssllabs.com/ssltest
  2. Paste your website address (e.g., https://yourcompany.com)
  3. Click “Submit”
  4. Wait 1–2 minutes for the results

How to Interpret the Results

SSL Labs gives a grade from A+ to F. Here’s what each grade means:

A or A+ — Excellent. Your SSL is configured correctly and uses the latest security standards. You can sleep well.

B — Acceptable, but there’s room for improvement. You’re probably using older protocols (TLS 1.0 or 1.1) for backward compatibility. For most small businesses this is enough, but it’s worth improving to an A.

C — Problematic. Your configuration has serious weaknesses. Some browsers may show warnings. This should be fixed as soon as possible.

D or F — Critical. Your SSL is configured so poorly that it practically doesn’t work. You’re losing customers every day.

Step 2: Check for Mixed Content

Besides SSL Labs, you must check whether your site loads any elements over HTTP:

  1. Open your website in Google Chrome
  2. Right-click > “Inspect” (or press F12)
  3. Go to the “Console” tab
  4. Refresh the page (F5)
  5. Look for warnings like “Mixed Content” or “insecure content”

If you see those warnings, you have a mixed content problem.

Step 3: Test in Different Browsers

Open your website in:

  • Google Chrome (desktop)
  • Firefox
  • Safari (if you have a Mac)
  • Chrome on your phone (Android and/or iOS)

In each browser, check whether:

  • A padlock icon appears in the address bar
  • There are no warnings
  • All images load
  • Forms work correctly

The Most Common Problems and How to Fix Them

Here’s a practical guide to the most typical SSL problems and their solutions:

Problem 1: Mixed Content

Symptoms: Missing images, an exclamation mark in the address bar, warnings in the browser console.

Solution:

If you use WordPress, the easiest way to fix this is with a plugin:

  1. Install the Really Simple SSL plugin
  2. Activate the plugin
  3. The plugin will automatically:
    • Detect mixed content
    • Change all HTTP links to HTTPS
    • Configure redirects
    • Fix most issues

Alternatively, you can manually find and replace all HTTP URLs with HTTPS in the database:

UPDATE wp_posts 
SET post_content = REPLACE(post_content, 'http://twojadomena.pl', 'https://twojadomena.pl');

UPDATE wp_postmeta 
SET meta_value = REPLACE(meta_value, 'http://twojadomena.pl', 'https://twojadomena.pl');

Note: Make a database backup before running these queries!

Problem 2: No Automatic Let’s Encrypt Renewal

Symptoms: The certificate expired, red warning for all users.

Solution:

Most good hosting providers renew Let’s Encrypt certificates automatically. If yours doesn’t:

  1. Log in to your hosting panel (cPanel, Plesk, DirectAdmin)
  2. Find the “SSL/TLS” or “Security” section
  3. Check if there’s an “Auto-renew” option for Let’s Encrypt
  4. Enable automatic renewal

If you can’t find that option, contact hosting support—this is a basic feature they should provide.

For more advanced users with SSH access:

# Check certbot status
sudo certbot renew --dry-run

# Add a cron job for automatic renewal
echo "0 0,12 * * * root python -c 'import random; import time; time.sleep(random.random() * 3600)' && certbot renew -q" | sudo tee -a /etc/crontab > /dev/null

Problem 3: No HTTP → HTTPS Redirect

Symptoms: The site is available on both HTTP and HTTPS, duplicate content.

Solution for WordPress:

  1. Log in to the WordPress admin panel
  2. Go to Settings > General
  3. Change both URLs from http:// to https://
  4. Save changes

Then add a redirect in the .htaccess file (in the site’s root folder):

# Force HTTPS
RewriteEngine On
RewriteCond %{HTTPS} off
RewriteRule ^(.*)$ https://%{HTTP_HOST}%{REQUEST_URI} [L,R=301]

Alternatively, if you use Nginx, add this to your configuration:

server {
    listen 80;
    server_name twojadomena.pl www.twojadomena.pl;
    return 301 https://twojadomena.pl$request_uri;
}

Problem 4: A Poor SSL Labs Grade (C, D, or F)

Symptoms: A low SSL Labs grade, warnings about outdated protocols.

Solution:

This usually requires access to the server configuration. For Apache, edit the SSL config file (usually /etc/apache2/sites-available/default-ssl.conf):

# Disable old protocols
SSLProtocol all -SSLv2 -SSLv3 -TLSv1 -TLSv1.1

# Use strong ciphers
SSLCipherSuite ECDHE-ECDSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256:ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256:ECDHE-ECDSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384:ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384

# Prefer server ciphers
SSLHonorCipherOrder on

For Nginx:

ssl_protocols TLSv1.2 TLSv1.3;
ssl_ciphers 'ECDHE-ECDSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256:ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256:ECDHE-ECDSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384:ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384';
ssl_prefer_server_ciphers on;

After making changes, restart the server:

sudo systemctl restart apache2  # or nginx

Note: If you don’t have server access or you’re not comfortable editing these files, ask your hosting provider for help or contact me.

Problem 5: The Certificate Doesn’t Match the Domain

Symptoms: The warning “Certificate does not match the domain name.”

Solution:

This happens when:

  • The certificate is issued for www.domain.com but you’re visiting domain.com (or vice versa)
  • You bought a certificate for one domain but you’re using it for another
  • The certificate expired and was replaced by the server’s default certificate

Solution:

  1. Check which exact domain the certificate was issued for (click the padlock > “Certificate” in your browser)
  2. Make sure you use a wildcard certificate (*.domain.com) if you support multiple subdomains
  3. For Let’s Encrypt, generate a certificate covering all versions of the domain:
sudo certbot certonly --apache -d domena.pl -d www.domena.pl

Why This Is About Trust, Not Tech

Most business owners think of SSL as a “technical formality.” That’s a fundamental mistake.

SSL is not just data encryption. It’s a visual signal of trust for your customers.

The Psychology of Security Warnings

When a user sees the red warning “Your connection is not private,” their brain gets a very simple message: this site is not safe—run.

It doesn’t matter that your company has existed for 20 years, that you have references from hundreds of clients, that your product is the best on the market. The user sees the warning and their self-preservation instinct tells them to close the tab.

It’s exactly as destructive as if your brick-and-mortar store had a broken window, a trashed sign, and graffiti on the wall. The customer thinks “something’s off” and simply goes to a competitor.

First Contact Decides Everything

UX studies show that users form an opinion about your website (and your business) in 0.05 seconds—50 milliseconds. That’s faster than a single blink.

If their first contact with your brand is a security warning, you’ve already lost. There is no second chance to make a first impression.

SSL as a Basic Hygiene Factor

In 2025, properly configured SSL isn’t a competitive advantage. It’s a basic hygiene factor. It’s like cleanliness in a restaurant—nobody chooses a restaurant “because it’s clean,” but everyone will avoid a restaurant that’s dirty.

Your competitors have SSL. Google expects SSL. Users expect SSL. If you don’t have it, you’re behind.

Case Study: How Fixing SSL Increased Conversions by 67%

I worked with a small training company from Poznań that sold online courses. They had a nice website, a solid offer, and they were actively promoting themselves on social media. The problem? Their conversion rate was catastrophically low—only 1.2% of visitors signed up for a free webinar.

Diagnosis

After 15 minutes of analysis I found the issue: their SSL certificate had expired 3 weeks earlier. Everyone who tried to enter the website saw a red warning. Most people simply closed the tab.

Interestingly, the owner didn’t see it at all—they were using Chrome, which had a previously cached version of the certificate. Only when I checked the site on a fresh browser installation did the issue show up.

Solution

Within 2 hours:

  1. I generated a new Let’s Encrypt certificate
  2. I configured automatic renewal
  3. I fixed mixed content (a few old images were still loading over HTTP)
  4. I added an HTTP → HTTPS redirect
  5. I improved the server configuration to an A grade in SSL Labs

Results

Within 7 days after the fix:

  • Conversion rate increased from 1.2% to 2.0% (+67%)
  • Bounce rate dropped from 78% to 41% (users stopped fleeing immediately)
  • Average time on site increased from 23 seconds to 3 minutes 12 seconds
  • 12 new webinar sign-ups (vs. 4 in the previous week)

Same traffic sources (Google Ads + social media), same landing pages, same offer. The only difference? Working SSL.

Webs Butler Can Fix Your SSL in a Few Hours

If you read this article and thought “this sounds complicated, I’d rather have someone just fix it for me”—I’ve got good news.

What I Offer

Quick SSL diagnosis (free):

  • Complete check of your SSL certificate
  • Mixed content test across the entire website
  • Server configuration analysis
  • A report with the exact issues and their impact on conversions

SSL repair (from 300 PLN):

  • Installation/renewal of the certificate
  • Configuration of automatic renewal
  • Fixing mixed content
  • HTTP → HTTPS redirects
  • Optimization of server configuration to an A grade in SSL Labs
  • Testing in all popular browsers

Guarantee:

  • Fix completed within a maximum of 24 hours after receiving access
  • An A or B grade in SSL Labs or your money back
  • 30 days of post-sale support

Why You Can Trust Webs Butler

I specialize in building and optimizing WordPress websites for small and medium businesses in Poland. I understand that not every business owner is a developer—and shouldn’t have to be. Your expertise is your industry; my expertise is technology.

I won’t “bury you in jargon” or “sell you services you don’t need.” If you can fix the issue yourself using this article—great. You’ll save money. If you’d rather have someone do it for you quickly and professionally—I’m here.

Contact me and describe your issue. Within 24 hours you’ll receive a free diagnosis and a repair quote.

You can also use a free consultation, where we’ll discuss not only SSL, but your entire online presence, and I’ll propose a comprehensive improvement plan.

And if you’re only planning to build a new website or redesign an existing one, check out my interactive pricing form—you’ll choose the features yourself and immediately see an estimated cost.

Checklist: Is Your SSL Configured Correctly?

Print this checklist and verify each point:

Basics:

  • [ ] SSL certificate is installed
  • [ ] Certificate is valid (not expired)
  • [ ] Certificate covers all domains you use (with www and without www)
  • [ ] Automatic renewal is enabled

Redirects:

  • [ ] HTTP automatically redirects to HTTPS
  • [ ] www redirects to non-www (or vice versa—you must choose one standard)
  • [ ] Old HTTP subpages redirect to their HTTPS equivalents

Mixed Content:

  • [ ] All images load over HTTPS
  • [ ] All JavaScript scripts load over HTTPS
  • [ ] All CSS stylesheets load over HTTPS
  • [ ] All external fonts load over HTTPS
  • [ ] There are no warnings in the browser console

Server Configuration:

  • [ ] A or B grade in SSL Labs
  • [ ] TLS 1.2 and 1.3 are enabled
  • [ ] Old protocols (SSL 2.0, 3.0, TLS 1.0, 1.1) are disabled
  • [ ] Strong encryption ciphers are used

User Experience:

  • [ ] A padlock icon appears in the address bar in all browsers
  • [ ] No security warnings
  • [ ] The site loads fast (SSL does not slow it down)
  • [ ] All features work (forms, payments, etc.)

Monitoring:

  • [ ] You have certificate expiration monitoring set up (email alert 30 days before)
  • [ ] You regularly (once per quarter) check SSL Labs
  • [ ] No HTTPS-related errors in Google Search Console

If any box is unchecked—you have a problem to fix.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a free Let’s Encrypt certificate worse than a paid one?

No. Technologically, Let’s Encrypt provides exactly the same encryption as paid certificates. The only differences are the validity period (90 vs. 365 days) and no extended validation (EV). For 99% of small businesses, Let’s Encrypt is more than sufficient.

How often should I check my SSL?

At minimum once per quarter. Ideally, set up automatic monitoring (many hosting providers offer it for free). Also check SSL any time after: changing hosting, updating WordPress, adding new subdomains.

Does SSL slow down my website?

Modern SSL certificates with HTTP/2 actually speed up websites rather than slow them down. The old “SSL slows things down” myth comes from the HTTP/1.1 era and is no longer true.

What if my hosting provider doesn’t offer free SSL?

Change hosting. In 2025, hosting without free Let’s Encrypt is simply bad hosting. Check my hosting migration offer—I’ll move your website to better hosting and configure SSL as part of the service.

Can I have SSL only on the payment page and leave the rest on HTTP?

Technically yes, but it’s a terrible idea. Google penalizes sites without HTTPS, users don’t trust sites without a padlock, and the browser will show a warning on first contact anyway. In 2025, your entire website must be on HTTPS.

Summary: Don’t Lose More Leads Because of Misconfigured SSL

84% of users leave a website when they see an SSL warning. That’s not a statistic you can ignore.

If your site has SSL issues—you’re losing real customers every day. Every day someone sees the warning, closes the tab, and goes to your competitor. Every day you’re leaving money on the table.

The good news? Fixing it takes 2 hours and often costs less than lunch at a restaurant.

Next steps:

  1. Now: Go to ssllabs.com/ssltest and check your SSL (2 minutes)
  2. Today: If your grade is C or lower, contact me for a free diagnosis
  3. This week: Fix the issue and stop losing customers

Don’t put it off. Every day is more lost leads. Every day is money you’re handing to your competitors.


Article last updated: January 2025. All procedures and tools were up to date at the time of publication. If you notice anything that needs updating, let me know.


Need help with SSL? Contact me—I’ll run a free diagnosis and fix the issue within 24 hours, before you lose more leads.

Why Your Website Is Losing Customers Due to SSL Issues

Imagine this situation: a potential customer searches for your services on Google, clicks the link to your website, and instead of seeing your offer, they see a red warning: “Your connection is not private.” What do they do? In 84% of cases, they simply close the tab and go to your competitor. This isn’t a […]

Dowiedz się więcej
})